Black Drum Vs Sheepshead – Know What is Biting! (Explained)

juvenile black drum vs sheepshead

Black Drum vs Sheepshead: There are various types of fish that anglers target in the waters nearshore and offshore, but two species tend to cause the most confusion among fishers: black drum and Sheepshead.

While they may look similar, they have very different habits and preferred habitats, so anglers need to be able to identify them correctly to choose the best lure or bait.

In this complete guide, we will compare and contrast these two species so you can learn how to tell them apart, and anglers catch black drums and sheepshead with rods and reels spooled!

Are Drum and Sheepshead the Same Fish?

The short answer is no; drums and Sheepshead are not the same fish. They may look similar, but they belong to different families and have other habits.

Black drums are a type of saltwater fish that belongs to the Sciaenidae family, including other species of fish such as redfish, croaker, and weakfish.

They are relatively large fish, with adults reaching up to four feet long and weighing 100 pounds.

Sheepshead, on the other hand, is a type of freshwater fish that belongs to the Porgies family, which includes other species such as perch and sunfish.

They are much smaller than a black drum, with adults only reaching light to medium weight up to two feet in length and weighing 15 pounds.

How to Tell Drum and Sheepshead Apart

Now that we know that drum and Sheepshead are not the exact fish let’s look at how to tell them apart.

The easiest way to tell these two fish apart is by looking at their teeth. Black drums have large, round teeth designed for crushing shells, while Sheepshead has small, sharp teeth to eat small crustaceans.

Another way to tell these two fish apart is by looking at their fins. Black drums have long, pointed fins for swimming long distances, while Sheepshead has short, stubby fins used for short bursts of speed.

Finally, you can also tell these two fish apart by looking at their tails. Black drums have long, curved tails used for steering, while Sheepshead has short, square seats for balance.

What’s the Difference Between Black Drum and Sheepshead? (Sheepshead Vs Black Drum)

Now that we experienced some of the ways you can tell black drum and Sheepshead apart, let’s look at some of the key differences between these two species of fish.

The Sheepshead has a long, broadly-shaped head with prominent front teeth.

Its mouth is surrounded by sharp canine incisors that can bite through flesh with little effort on behalf of the fish’s powerful jaws muscles (not to mention their pointed noses!).

On top, there are two finlike structures; one located just below where you’d expect your eyes would be if looking at them straight ahead while standing up – this part represents its upper slightly more advanced generations.,

And then another further back which appears hockey stick like due almost entirely because it grows faster than any other area during early life stages

Habitat Differences

Black drum and Sheepshead also differ in terms of their preferred habitats. Black drums are typically found in saltwater environments such as bays, estuaries, the Gulf of Mexico, and North Carolina coastal waters in the United States.

They are bottom-dwelling fish, so they often inhabit areas with sandy or muddy bottoms.

Sheepshead, on the other hand, is typically found in freshwater environments such as lakes, rivers, and streams.

They are also bottom-dwelling fish, but they prefer areas with rocky bottoms.

Diet Differences

Another significant difference between these two fish is their diet. Black drums feed on various items, including crabs, shrimp, oysters, and small fish.

Sheepshead, on the other hand, primarily feed on crustaceans such as barnacles, crabs, and shrimp.

Spawning Differences

Finally, black drum and Sheepshead also differ in their spawning habits. Black drums typically spawn in the spring and summer months, with peak spawning activity occurring in May and June.

On the other hand, Sheepshead typically spawns in the winter and spring months, with peak spawning activity occurring in February and March.

As you see, there are many ways to tell black drum and Sheepshead apart “black drum vs sheepshead”. By taking the time to learn about these two species, you’ll be able to choose the best lure or bait for your next fishing trip.

Is Black Drum Good Eating?

The meat of a black drum fish is coarse, so it doesn’t make the best choice for raw dishes. However, sashimi and ceviche are recommended preparations with this type of FDA-approved food!

Is Sheepshead Good Eating?

The short answer is yes – a sheepshead is good to eat! Many people say that they taste even better than a black drum. The meat of Sheepshead is white and flaky, and it has a mild flavor that some people compare to lobster.

So, if you’re looking for a delicious fish to cook for your next meal, Sheepshead is an excellent choice.

Are Black Drum and Sheepshead Related? (Juvenile Black Drum Vs. Sheepshead)

The black drum fish is a fish with an appearance that could be mistaken for the Sheepshead. However, they are not exactly alike, and there are some essential differences between them to take into account when catching whichever one you find in your local waters to know more about black drum vs sheepshead!

What Fish Looks Like a Sheepshead?

A juvenile black drum looks like a sheepshead, with its long and broad head and large canine teeth.

The main difference is that the black drum’s mouth is located more on the underside of its head, while the Sheepshead is closer to the front.

The juvenile black drum is not the only fish with a similar appearance.

Other cartilaginous animals, such as black drums and Atlantic spadefishes with barbels on their lower jaws. Still, they can be distinguished by size: while most varieties grow larger than an adult sheep, some get close enough for you!

What Is the Best Bait for Sheepshead? (Secret Sheepshead Bait)

Some of the best baits for Sheepshead include live shrimp, live fiddler crabs, and live oysters. You can also use dead baits such as cut shrimp, squid, or crab meat.

When choosing a bait, it’s essential to select something that Sheepshead is eating. Otherwise, you’re just wasting your time (and bait).

To find out what Sheepshead is eating in your area, you can talk to local anglers, check fishing reports, or experiment with different baits until you find something that works.

MOTZU Set of 10 Artificial Crab Baits, 3D Simulation Crab Soft Lures...
  • Lifelike -- Biomimetic design makes it looks like a real crab...
  • Versatility -- Can be used to catch a variety of fish like Bream,...
  • Attraction -- Bright colors to attract big fish and it with...
  • Good Quality -- Made of high quality silicone with fine...
3Pcs Crab Bait 3D Simulation Crab Soft Lures with Sharp Hooks Double...
  • 【Sharp Hook】The double hook helps avoid hooked fish coming...
  • 【Good Quality】The crab bait made of PVC looks like the real...
  • 【3 Styles】You will get 3 styles of this sort of crab bait
  • 【Versatility】This simulated crab bait with sharp hook is...
Berkley Gulp! Peeler Crab Natural Peeler, 2in
  • Number One in Fishing sports
  • Manufactured in the country of China
  • Made of the Highest quality material
2 Pack Soft Fish Fishing Crab Lures Bait with Sharp Hooks,Simulation...
  • 🎣【PACKAGE INCLUDING】 2PCS Soft Fishing Crab Lures with...
  • 🎣【 LIFELIKE DESIGN】Crab bait has bright colors to attract...
  • 🎣【COMFORTABLE MATERIAL】Using environmentally-friendly...
minihut 5 Pack Soft Fish Fishing Crab Lures Bait Artificial with Sharp...
  • Soft Fishing Crab Lures, new Exquisite details, sharp hook
  • Crab bait has bright colors to attract big fish:black,...
  • Air-filled claws for exceptional underwater action
  • Lifelike appearance. Top saltwater colors
LIOOBO 3pcs Artificial Fishing Lure Baits Soft Crab Fish Baits with...
  • Artificial 3D Simulation Crab Lure Baits Simulation Soft Fish...
  • Ideal fishing lures for fishing lovers.Made of material, they are...
  • The detailed patterns and life-like colors simulate crab bait,...
  • It is a great gift to any beginner or addictive anglers.

Secret Sheepshead Bait

Live hermit crabs are one of the perfect (and most underrated) baits for Sheepshead. These tiny crustaceans are easy to find, and they’re a favorite food of Sheepshead.

It isn’t easy to rig a hermit crab as bait, thread it onto a hook, and cast the perfect sheepshead bait, but it’s worth the effort.

Once you find a bait that Sheepshead can’t resist, you’ll be catching them in no time.

Can a Sheepshead Fish Hurt You? (Do Sheepshead Have Teeth?)

Yes, They can hurt you. Sheepshead fish have sharp teeth to eat crabs, shrimp, and other small creatures.

These teeth can easily puncture the skin, so it’s essential to be careful when handling Sheepshead. It’s also a good idea to wear gloves when fishing for them.

Why Do Sheepshead Have Rocks in Their Head?

Contrary to popular belief, Sheepshead does not have rocks in its head. The rigid, bony plates that you can see on their heads are called scutes.

Scutes are made of keratin, the same material that makes up human fingernails. They’re used for protection, and they help the Sheepshead to blend in with their surroundings.

What Type of Fish Is a Drum?

A drum is a type of fish that belongs to the Sciaenidae family. This family includes species such as the red drum, black drum, spotted seatrout, and croaker.

Drums are characterized by their long bodies and largemouth. They have two dorsal fins, and the second dorsal fin is usually taller than the first.

Drums are found in both saltwater and freshwater environments. They’re popular gamefish because of their fighting ability and their tasty flesh.

What Does Drum Fish Taste Like?

Drumfish has a mild, sweet flavor. Their flesh is white and flaky, with a firm texture.

Drums are often compared to other mild-flavored fish such as tilapia bottom feeder or catfish. However, they have a slightly sweeter taste that sets them apart from other fish in this flavor profile.

Does Drum Fish Have Worms?

Yes, drum fish can have worms. These worms are called spaghetti worms, and they’re usually found in the muscle tissue of the fish.

The spaghetti worms are a common problem for saltwater fish such as speckled and white trout, black drum, or redfish. These flatworms look alike to most anglers, but they’re not exactly alike because some use these host animals while others don’t!

Can You Eat Freshwater Sheepshead Fish?

Yes, you can eat freshwater sheepshead fish. They’re a popular game fish known for their mild, sweet flavor.

Freshwater Sheepshead is found in lakes, rivers, and streams. They’re a popular target for anglers because they’re relatively easy to catch, making excellent table fare.


Black Drum and Sheephead are two different types of fish. -Black Drum is typically a saltwater fish, while Sheepshead can be found in brackish and saltwater. -Sheepshead has vertical black stripes from its eye to its gill cover, while Black Drum does not have this marking. -The easiest way to tell the difference between the two fish is by their teeth. So, what’s biting in the Tampa Bay area? Fishing for black drum or Sheepshead. If you’re targeting one or both of these fish, use live bait such as shrimp or crabs to increase your chances of success. Be sure to read this complete Black Drum vs Sheepshead Comparison before fishing!

You might also like:

Spread the love
error: Content is protected !!
Scroll to Top